Skip to main content

MLB Props Results

Saturday, May 23, 2026 ET

17/20 props hit (85%)

These are the MLB player props we tracked on Saturday, May 23, 2026 ET. Each prop shows whether it hit or missed, along with the hit rate and confidence rating it carried going into the game. See all MLB players to dig into individual trends.

Results(20)

Tyler HeinemanBPIT @ TOR
Under 0.5H/R/RBIMedium
8/10 L10-115 @ theScore BetUpdated May 23
Miss ✗Actual: 3
Luke Keaschall2BMIN @ BOS
2+H/R/RBIMedium
5/10 L10-110 @ BetMGMUpdated May 23
Hit ✓Actual: 4
Luke Keaschall2BMIN @ BOS
1+Total BasesMedium
6/10 L10-190 @ theScore BetUpdated May 23
Hit ✓Actual: 2
Evan CarterCFTEX @ LAA
Under 1.5Total BasesMedium
8/10 L10-260 @ theScore BetUpdated May 24
Hit ✓Actual: 0
Jorge BarrosaCFCOL @ ARI
Under 1.5H/R/RBIMedium
9/10 L10-130 @ theScore BetUpdated May 24
Hit ✓Actual: 0
Jordan WalkerRFSTL @ CIN
Under 0.5SBMedium
10/10 L10🔥 10G Elite Streak-1120 @ DraftKingsUpdated May 23
Hit ✓Actual: 0
Jorge BarrosaCFCOL @ ARI
Under 1.5Total BasesMedium
10/10 L10-190 @ theScore BetUpdated May 24
Hit ✓Actual: 0
Tyler StephensonBSTL @ CIN
Under 1.5Total BasesMedium
9/10 L10-200 @ theScore BetUpdated May 23
Hit ✓Actual: 0
Xander BogaertsSSATH @ SD
Under 1.5Total BasesMedium
9/10 L10-220 @ theScore BetUpdated May 24
Miss ✗Actual: 2
Jordan WalkerRFSTL @ CIN
Under 0.5SBMedium
10/10 L10🔥 10G Elite Streak-1400 @ BetMGMUpdated May 23
Hit ✓Actual: 0
Will BensonBSTL @ CIN
Under 1.5H/R/RBIMedium
9/10 L10-150 @ DraftKingsUpdated May 23
Hit ✓Actual: 1
Ian HappLFHOU @ CHC
Under 1.5H/R/RBIMedium
8/10 L10-130 @ theScore BetUpdated May 23
Hit ✓Actual: 1
Tyler HeinemanBPIT @ TOR
Under 1.5RunsMedium
10/10 L10🔥 10G Elite Streak-7500 @ theScore BetUpdated May 23
Hit ✓Actual: 1
Victor Scott IICFSTL @ CIN
Under 1.5H/R/RBIMedium
8/10 L10-150 @ theScore BetUpdated May 23
Miss ✗Actual: 4
Jorge BarrosaCFCOL @ ARI
Under 0.5SBMedium
10/10 L10🔥 10G Elite Streak-2000 @ BetMGMUpdated May 24
Hit ✓Actual: 0
Bryce JohnsonBATH @ SD
Under 1.5H/R/RBIMedium
10/10 L10-190 @ CaesarsUpdated May 24
Hit ✓Actual: 0
Tyler HeinemanBPIT @ TOR
Under 1.5SinglesMedium
10/10 L10-4000 @ theScore BetUpdated May 23
Hit ✓Actual: 0
Will BensonBSTL @ CIN
Under 1.5SinglesMedium
10/10 L10-4000 @ theScore BetUpdated May 23
Hit ✓Actual: 1
Nolan Gorman3BSTL @ CIN
Under 1.5Total BasesMedium
8/10 L10-178 @ DraftKingsUpdated May 23
Hit ✓Actual: 1
Masyn WinnSSSTL @ CIN
Under 0.5SBMedium
10/10 L10🔥 10G Elite Streak-1120 @ DraftKingsUpdated May 23
Hit ✓Actual: 0

How the day went

17/20 props hit — a 85% rate.

SB: 4/4. Singles: 2/2. Total Bases: 5/6.

Get exact confidence scores, EV%, all sportsbook odds, and full trend charts for every prop.

Frequently asked questions

How are MLB props ranked on this page?

Every prop is ranked by confidence, which comes from how consistently a player has hit a line in recent MLB games. A player who's gone over their points line in 9 of the last 10 games gets a higher confidence rating than someone at 5 of 10. We also factor in streaks and matchup context.

What do hit rates like "8/10 L10" mean?

"8/10 L10" means the prop hit in 8 of the player's last 10 MLB games. L5 is last 5 games. The higher the hit rate over a larger sample, the more reliable the trend. WagerLens tracks hit rates across 1, 3, 5, 7, and 10-game windows.

What happens to this page after MLB games on Saturday, May 23, 2026 ET finish?

Once games wrap up, this page updates to show results. Each prop gets a Hit or Miss tag based on the actual stat line. You can browse past dates to see how MLB props performed and spot which markets hit most often.